The Last Samurai

I’d heard noth­ing but bad about The Last Samu­rai. I saw it last night and was enter­tained. What brought it down the most was Tom Cruise. The direc­tor, one Mr. Zwick, end­ed up putting a bit too much empha­sis on Cruise, in nar­ra­tion, diegetic dia­logue, and pho­to-mon­tage. I got the dis­tinct impres­sion that the movie was main­ly filmed as anoth­er chance for Tom Cruise to play dress-up and over­come his own per­son­al demons on the way to con­quer­ing some real life bad­dies. [just like Top Gun, Far and Away, Minor­i­ty Report, etc.]

The bat­tle sequences were sweet, although the final bat­tle was­n’t quit as epic as it was bor­ing. I can only watch peo­ple get mowed down by muz­zle-load­ers, Gatling guns, and how­itzers for so long before I start to yawn. I was most impressed with the per­for­mances by the actu­al Japan­ese who played samu­rai. Cruise did a poor job fak­ing an under­stand­ing of the Japan­ese world­view. In typ­i­cal Hol­ly­wood fash­ion, every­thing was a dichoto­my. This does­n’t work too well when cast into an Asian set­ting. The clash between incom­ing West­ern cul­ture and tra­di­tion­al Japan­ese way of life does not real­ly come through. Of course, you can see it por­trayed but I don’t buy it. Tokyo is mod­ern­ized but the vil­lage Cruise fights for look com­plete­ly unchanged.

And of course, there is the sub­text of a fail­ing ‘Oth­er’ cul­ture that is revi­tal­ized by incom­ing West­ern­ers. Tom Cruise, it appears, is meant to teach the Japan­ese how to tap into ‘their great reser­voir of feel­ing’ or some­such. The Japan­ese have dis­ci­pline, but no good lead­er­ship. Even Kat­sumo­to, the great samu­rai, must learn a bit about hon­or and duty from Cruise. what­ev­er.

The token ref­er­ences to Bud­dhist ideas, land­scapes et cetera, would have been much more worth­while if they had been giv­en the time they deserved. of course, then the movie would have been about 5 hours long, but most like­ly worth that time as well.

This movie would have been about a gril­lion times bet­ter if it was Japan­ese pro­duced, direct­ed, cast­ed [with Cruise’s char­ac­ter slipped into a minor role] and edit­ed.

2 thoughts on “The Last Samurai”

Comments are closed.